johanley wrote:Another Season 8 episode, another reinforcement that Jack and Renee are single handedly salvaging the this year.
Truthfully, I didn't like the way they handled Renee in this episode or the resolution to her undercover op with Vlad. I mean, I knew that Renee killing Vlad was inevitably coming, they've been setting it up since Renee's return in episode 4. I knew that eventually he was going to get his just desserts at her hand, after what he put her through in both the backstory they established between them, the way he coerced her into his bed and the way he was smacking her around right before she stuck him.
But Renee going all PTSD and stabbing Jack? Sure, Werching acted it well, and I didn't see it coming either, but come on. All the build up of the last few episodes and the character development establishing this new edgy, dark and badass Renee who is willing to sacrifice her own soul, even her own life, for the sake of this mission culminates in a psychotic break, followed by her saying "Jack, you were right, I couldn't handle it" between sobs? This is the woman who cut off a guy's thumb without blinking two hours ago.
Don't get me wrong, it was still psychically satisfying to watch her stab Vlad two dozen times -- but how many times do we have to watch a woman kill the guy who hurt her iduring a psychotic break on this show? Renee can join the ranks of Elizabeth Nash, Teresa Ortega, that Russian sex slave from Season 5, Martha Logan, etc. It would have been a stronger choice to have Renee kill Vlad in cold blood because she felt he deserved to die for all he's done, including brutalizing her, and then have her wrestle with the consequences of that decision if they really wanted to sell the character progression they've been shilling. The whole thing left a bitter taste in my mouth. Then again, the lack of Tony has left a bitter taste in my mouth from the outset, so I'm probably not the most objective opinion here.
Now ... how is Bauer going to convince his superiors to keep Renee on the case after this, as we know she'll be in the show for the duration. Whatever it is, it better be good. Somehow, though, I don't think it will be good enough to convince me it's not laughable after her little stab-fest.
Kudos to those of you who are enjoying the Dana/Kevin storyline. I'm enjoying the viewing experience there too, but not in the way the writers are intending I don't think, unless they are intending pure comedy. The whole thing is idiocy from beginning to end, and I am laughing out loud, often, at how ridiculous it is. Even the dumbest criminal in the world isn't going to risk $120K in cash to root through some boxes of old water pistols. These two have just shot into the top 5 of the "Top 24 Biggest Imbeciles of 24" list if I ever get around to revising it. I particularly enjoyed the shot of them driving drunk in the final split screen before the preclock. That's just the cherry on top of the sundae. The idiocy of this storyline is an insult to viewers' intelligence after the calibre of writing we've come to expect from this show.
I have to say, though, it was absolutely badass when Jack pulled the knife Renee stabbed him with out of his torso and immediately chucked it into a bad guy's throat. Once again, if I ever get around to revising the "Top 24 Badass Jack Bauer Moments of 24" list, that will certainly assume a slot. Classic Bauer.